1890
Name of the Congregation: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Pastor: none listed
Total Membership: 60
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1890, page 154]

1891
Name of the Congregation: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Pastor: J. W. Hagler
Total Membership: 50
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1891, page 168]

1892
Name of the Congregation: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Pastor: none listed
Total Membership: 47
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1892, page 176]

1893
Name of the Congregation: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Pastor: none listed
Total Membership: 50
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1893, page 178]

1894
Name of the Congregation: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Pastor: L. D. Lewis
Total Membership: 49
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1894, page 192]

1895
Talledega Presbytery did not report

1896
Name of Congregation: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Pastor: L. D. Lewis
No. Communicants: 43
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1896, page 187]

1897
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Small, Henry, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister: Zwingle, J. H.
No. Communicants: 43
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1897, page 154]

1898
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister: J. H. Zwingle
No. Communicants: 87
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1898, page 175]

1899
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister: J. W. Duncan
No. Communicants: 70
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1899, page 69a]

1900
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister: R. G. Newsome
No. Communicants: 67
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1900, page 88a]

1901
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister: R. G. Newsome
No. Communicants: 54
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1901, page 114a]

1902
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post-Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister: none listed
Total No. of Members: 64
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1902, page 105a]

1903
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister Now In Charge: J. R. McMullen
Total Number of Members: 70
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1903, page 90a]

1904
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Henry Small, R. R. 1, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister Now In Charge: J. R. McMullen
Total Number of Members: 93
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1904, page 74a]

1905
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: H. Small, R. D. 1, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister Now In Charge: N. J. Callan
Total Number of Members: 79
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1905, page 55a]

1906
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Post Office: Henry Small, Collinsville, Ala.
Minister Now In Charge: G. C. Alexander
Total Number of Members: 58
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1906, page 47a]

1907
No Report from Bethel

1908
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Postoffice: none listed
Minister now in Charge: W. E. Brown
Total Number of Members: 20
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1908, page 6a]

1909
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Postoffice: unknown
Minister now in Charge: none listed
Total Number of Members: none listed
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1909, page 63a]

1910
Last time mentioned in the Presbyterial Reports to General Assembly
Name of Church: Bethel Cumberland Presbyterian Church
Clerk of the Session and Postoffice: unknown; in disorganized condition
Minister now in Charge: none listed
Total Number of Members: none listed
Talledaga Presbytery - Synod of Alabama
[Source: Minutes of the General Assembly of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, 1910, page 189]